Homemade music: don’t try this in Raleigh

My family and I spent Christmas Eve at my parents’ house. After dinner was over, we got out our instruments and played some music, starting with Christmas songs and then moving on to others, like the bluegrass classic Keep On The Sunnyside, as seen on YouTube. It had been a long time since I’d played with my brothers (and dad) and we all had a great time. It reminded me of something I’ve been considering for a while (actually, ever since my daughter Hallie began violin lessons): hosting a regular jam session at the house for anyone who wanted to come over and play.

That’s how music used to be made in this country, before the scourge of record companies. Folks used to gather ’round and play old folk songs and the like. There’s no better way to become a better musician than to play with other musicians, especially if it’s an informal session. I know many of my neighbors are musicians and I’d love to have them over to play. It would be a great way to get to know them and for them to get to know others. It definitely would make for a stronger community.

There’s only one problem with my little scheme: the City of Raleigh would come down hard on us. You see, according to Raleigh’s board of adjustment, we would only be allowed to host three of these events before the city would fine us. At least, that’s what they did to Bett Padgett when she generously opened her home to musicians on a regular basis. Rumor has it a business owner complained and the city’s inspections department clamped down on the Padgett’s house parties. For shame.

I’m trying to figure out just what this ordinance is supposed to protect against, seeing how the Padgetts’ parties were all indoors and did not disturb the peace in any way. Donations were accepted but not required, and all money went to the artist. As far as i know there was no beer or wine served, so what’s the problem?

On the other hand, Raleigh’s zoning code allows any home to become a church, with unlimited performances. The collection plate can be passed every week and Raleigh’s inspectors won’t bat an eye. Heck, Raleigh apparently doesn’t even care if the sermon can be heard blocks away, as is the case in my neighborhood with a church that turns it up a bit too loud (ad has been doing so for years without repercussions).

But host your own music event more than three times a year and the law will come down on you. This is just stupid. There’s no other way to say it. Raleigh needs to revisit its rules and let the music (and the musicians) play.